Fact Checking Claims

City Council candidates and current Planning Commissioners Santosh Rao and Tracy Kosolcharoen have made a number of false claims in their campaign statements. In the spirit of transparency and everyone working with the same set of facts, we are providing rebuttals to some of their most significant claims.

We'll add new rebuttals as new false claims are made, so keep checking back!

Santosh and Tracy claim "J.R., John, and Seema are bought by developers."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao and Tracy Kosolcharoen that is not based on real facts. 

The campaign donations to all candidates are public information and J.R., Seema, and John have not taken a single dime from developers. Instead, they have received over a hundred donations by individual Cupertino residents.

Santosh and Tracy have however taken donations from out-of-town developers who are actively opposing an affordable housing project in Cupertino. Each of them received a large donation of $4,000 from Brian and Regan Avery, owners of Glenbrook Apartments on Mary Avenue (ACCO is Avery Construction Company). Brian Avery has spoken at the City Council against the Mary Avenue Villas development. Are these donations a payment for Santosh and Tracy's "No" votes against the Mary Avenue Villas development in the Planning Commission meeting of February 10, 2026? Given the size of the donations, is it also payment for future votes? It certainly gives the impression of "Pay to Play".

Claim: "J.R., John, and Seema are Pro-Development While Tracy, Santosh, and Gopal are Pro-Residents"

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao and Tracy Kosolcharoen not based on real facts. 

Labels are not a record. J.R. and Seema have a demonstrated track record of delivering results that improve the lives of residents - the Regnart Creek trail, safer streets, safer intersections, thoughtful balanced growth in housing for all demographics, fiscal strength, streamlined permits, reduced red tape, and more.

John, Seema, and J.R. are MORE pro-resident than the "pro-resident" Better Cupertino candidates because they support ALL residents including renters, students, seniors, dog owners, cyclists, and pickleball players. In contrast, the Better Cupertino candidates voted to kill the 100% affordable housing project at Mary Avenue, tried to kill the Bike Ped Commission and the Active Transportation Plan, tried to kill the Dog Off Leash Areas (DOLAs), tried to kill the city's pickleball community, and tried to remove the protected bike lanes on Stevens Creek Boulevard that keep our kids safe as they bike to school.

There are no instances of proposed developments where J.R., Seema, and John supported the project but it was not also supported by a Better Cupertino Councilmember or Planning Commissioner. In fact, the Planning Commission with Seema, Tracy, and Santosh, voted together to approve ALL housing developments except the Mary Ave Villas project.

 

Santosh and Tracy claim "J.R., John, and Seema Want To Make Cupertino Densely Populated with Tall Buildings Everywhere."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao and Tracy Kosolcharoen not based on real facts. 

J.R., Seema, and John have spoken multiple times in Council, Planning Commission, and other public meetings about the need for thoughtful, balanced housing growth which maintains the character of the city and the quality of life we all cherish. They have never advocated for a more urban, densely populated city with tall buildings everywhere. They have never advocated for tall buildings at street corners in residential neighborhoods. They have never advocated for Vallco to have tall buildings.

In a recent candidate debate held by the Cupertino Rotary and the Chamber of Commerce, J.R., Seema, and John all said that higher density developments should be placed on the major commercial corridors, and that density should be added thoughtfully with as much local control as possible, while ensuring it fits within its surrounding neighborhoods.

For the planned Vallco, development, all three advocate for the city to lead a community input process for residents to design a proposed new downtown at Vallco, in partnership with Sandhill, the developer. This would be similar to the community input process that the city followed to develop the Tier 2 Specific Plan which gave the city over $100 million in community benefits, but was subsequently abandoned by the Better Cupertino-majority City Council.

 

Tracy "approved roadway safety improvements for pedestrians and bicyclists."

This is a misleading statement by Tracy Kosolcharoen not based on real facts. 

In fact, she tried to gut the plan first. In the July 14, 2026 Planning Commission meeting, Tracy twice seconded the motion by Santosh Rao and voted with him to strip major elements from the Active Transportation Plan — once to remove separated bike lanes, once to block anything affecting parking on Blaney, Miller, Bollinger, and Stelling. Both votes failed 3-2. Only then did she vote to approve it, admitting on the dais that she didn't have the votes to weaken it.

Tracy Kosolcharoen also has a documented history of advocating for policies that reduce the city's support for walking and biking. She spoke at a Council meeting in favor of disbanding the Bike Ped Commission and moving its responsibilities to the Planning Commission. In April 2026, she argued against the protected bike lanes on Stevens Creek Boulevard during a CIP review agenda item on the Planning Commission, claiming without proof that they would slow down emergency response times. All transportation projects are reviewed and approved by the Sheriff's Office and Fire Department before they can proceed to implementation, a fact of which Tracy was unaware.

Tracy "proposed programs to help displaced businesses."

This is a false statement by Tracy Kosolcharoen not based on real facts. 

It was in fact Seema Lindskog who proposed this. In the March 24, 2026 Planning Commission meeting, when a new development project was discussed that will displace Panera and Voyager Coffee, Commissioner Seema Lindskog pushed for real relocation help from the developer, the city, and the Chamber of Commerce — and got the developer to cover all of Voyager's relocation and permitting costs. Commissioner Lindskog's motion passed 5-0.

Tracy "championed faster permitting for home upgrades and businesses."

This is a false statement by Tracy Kosolcharoen not based on real facts. 

Seema Lindskog proposed this at the Planning Commission meeting on Feb 13, 2024 where it was unanimously approved — a full year before Tracy even joined the Planning Commission.

Seema Lindskog personally pitched these projects in 1:1 coffees to Mayor Liang Chao, Councilmembers Ray Wang, JR Fruen, and Sheila Mohan on January 5-9, 2025 and she spoke in support at the Jan 22, 2025 Council meeting. The project to simplify permits for simple home upgrades and repairs and the Canopy Plan both got adopted as City Work Program items in March 2025. Tracy didn't touch the issue until July 2026 — 1.5 years after Seema started it —when staff brought a status update to the Planning Commission.

Santosh stopped "an attempt to take down the Cupertino Sports Center in 2023."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

Neither J.R., Seema, nor the city ever attempted to “take down the Sports Center”. There was a Council meeting on Oct 17 2023 where the council discussed options for City Hall. The current City Hall is seismically unsafe as discussed in the City Council as early as 2005 and needs serious repairs or a full replacement. Here's the video of the staff presentation where they proposed combining renovating/replacing City Hall with renovating/replacing the Sports Center while "maintaining access to the Sports Center facilities", here's the video where J.R. seconds Mayor Hung Wei's motion to specifically exclude the Cupertino Sports Center from any development plans and here's the video of the entire council deliberations. The final motion proposed by Mayor Hung Wei and seconded by J.R. Fruen passed 3-2 with Moore and Chao voting no because they didn't agree with the plan to renovate or replace City Hall. 

Santosh stopped "an attempt to put a Bollinger Road traffic study that would have reduced Bollinger to a one-lane road."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

There has never been a project that proposed to reduce one lane each way on Bollinger Road to the Bike Ped Commission, the Planning Commission, or the City Council. 

On May 15, 2025, the Council considered the funding for a Bollinger Road Corridor Study proposal in the Capital Improvement budget. The study – which does not recommend any road changes – was intended to investigate how the city could address the safety issues on Bollinger Road which have led to two fatalities and many serious injuries. The road was identified as a top injury corridor in the Vision Zero Plan, and involves significant student traffic from Hyde Middle, Lynbrook High and Eaton Elementary schools. This safety study was supported by a $425,000 grant.

The study was cancelled (and the grant thrown away) by the Better Cupertino-majority City Council (Ray Wang, Liang Chao, and Kitty Moore) with Santosh Rao speaking against the study as a resident at the Council meeting. Councilmember J.R. Fruen, who lives on Bollinger, was recused from the entire discussion and could not have any influence on what such a study would include.

Santosh stopped "an attempt to join the Stevens Creek Corridor Study that would have turned one lane of Stevens Creek in each direction into a dedicated VTA lane."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

Since 2020, Cupertino has been (and legally remains) a member of the Stevens Creek Corridor Vision Study Steering Committee together with the County of Santa Clara, the City of Santa Clara, the City of San Jose, and the Valley Transportation Authority. The idea that the city “made an attempt to join” this study is both factually and legally incorrect. 

Moreover, there has never been any recommendation from the Stevens Creek Corridor Vision Study Steering Committee or VTA to convert a lane on Stevens Creek Boulevard into a dedicated VTA bus lane.

Santosh claims to be "the only candidate to vote no on the Evulich Ct development."

Santosh Rao is not being honest about his vote on the Evulich Ct development. The Planning Commission vote on the Evulich project was on Feb 24 2026. All five commissioners were in favor of approving the project. The disagreement was only on whether to include a trail connection to the Linda Vista segment of the Stevens Creek Trail. See video here.

  • Santosh Rao moved and Steven Scharf seconded to approve the project WITHOUT the trail connection. The motion was not voted on.
  • Seema Lindskog made a substitute motion and David Fung seconded to approve the project WITH the trail connection. The motion passed with Lindskog, Fung, and Kosolcharoen voting in favor, Rao and Scharf voting against.

Santosh stopped "an ongoing attempt to give away Mary Avenue for $1 and in a manner that has not been vetted."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

The city’s General Plan includes a commitment to the state to allow and to subsidize a unique affordable housing project along Mary Avenue using portions of existing underutilized city-owned parking spaces near the Dog Park. The City Council fulfilled its commitment by approving this much-needed affordable housing for extremely low income intellectually and developmentally disabled adult residents. Councilmembers J.R. Fruen, Sheila Mohan, and Kitty Moore voted to advance this critical project, with Councilmembers Liang Chao and Ray Wang voting no.

Failure to approve the project would have jeopardized the city's compliance with state housing laws. Indeed, far from “giving away” Mary Avenue, the street will receive improvements as a result of these approvals, including a new sidewalk where none presently exists.

Santosh stopped "an attempt to upzone Stevens Creek Boulevard into SB79 eligible with one mile of multi-family in each direction."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts.

SB 79 is a state law, passed in 2025 and operative as of July 1, 2026, that creates a ministerial approval process for qualifying housing-focused projects within proximity of certain, well-defined transit stops. No such stops meet these definitions in Cupertino, or anywhere else along Stevens Creek Boulevard. 

Floating bus stops – stops placed on a sidewalk separating a bike lane from the bus or vehicular traffic lanes – were discussed briefly for about 45 seconds in the Planning Commission meeting of July 14, 2026, but there was no action requested or voted upon. Floating bus stops are not planned to be implemented on Stevens Creek Blvd because the city and the VTA could not agree on a design to implement. 

Regardless, floating bus stops do not trigger SB 79 eligibility. SB 79 eligibility links to certain types of transit stops, like fixed rail, that are specifically defined in the law. Floating bus stops don’t qualify.

Santosh "held every public dollar accountable to long-horizon community value on the CUSD Measure Z Bond Oversight Committee."

This is a misleading statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

Membership in a group does not equate accomplishment. Every bond issue has a taxpayer oversight committee, which requires representation from specific segments.  Santosh Rao was the sole “senior” applicant.  The role consists of reviewing financials. 

Santosh Rao has given public comment to the CUSD board demanding that his child’s elementary school get more funding without a clear understanding of how the district distributes funds from their bond. He demanded that Faria receive twice the amount as other schools because they have twice the amount of students at that school. This is not how a school district determines needs - they must prioritize age of facilities and renovation needs. 

Santosh Rao also did not realize that Measure Z bond has several phases where the district can release the funds and that Faria was slated for their projects at a later date.  This should be basic knowledge for someone who is serving on the oversight committee.

Santosh stopped "an attempt to open up the Vallco wall because of community input from outsiders."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

A group of Cupertino residents and neighbors spoke to the City Council in support of creating a pedestrian gate in the wall between the planned Wolfe Rd Educator Housing and the Portal neighborhood to allow kids to walk and bike to Collins Elementary and Lawson Middle Schools using small residential streets instead of having to do a big detour on Stevens Creek Boulevard which would require them to be driven to school, adding cars to the road and contributing to the dropoff and pickup time neighborhood gridlocks. This effort was led by the resident group Walk Bike Cupertino, whose board members are all long time Cupertino residents with deep roots in the community. This was not - by any definition - an “outsider” led effort.

Santosh claims "J.R. and Seema are running without a track record that they’re willing to talk about."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

Seema and JR are running extensively on their significant record of delivering real results for residents as evidenced throughout the Cupertino Together website and campaign materials. This includes:

  • Saved the city over $60 million dollars in the Apple sales tax negotiations (J.R.)
  • Advanced the Vallco development by resolving remaining legal disputes with the property owner (J.R.)
  • Passed a state-certified Housing Element to ensure orderly growth that meets Cupertino’s housing needs (J.R.)
  • Approved hundreds of high-quality new homes for families near amenities and transit (J.R.)
  • Reformed council governance through the drafting and adoption of a Council Procedures Manual leading to shorter, more productive council meetings that respect the public’s time and money (J.R.)
  • Revised Council’s Ethics Code to improve standards of conduct for councilmembers and commissioners (J.R.)
  • Championed reform of old commercial zoning standards to promote economic development in the Heart of the City. (J.R.)
  • Approved the Mary Avenue Villas project for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. (J.R. and Seema)
  • Delivered the Regnart Creek trail (Seema)
  • Streamlined and simplified accessory dwelling unit (ADU) permitting (J.R. and Seema)
  • Got the city to agree in March 2025 to simplify permitting for common repairs and upgrades (Seema)
  • Got the city to agree in March 2025 to develop a small business revitalization plan (Seema)
  • Got the developer to cover all relocation and permitting costs for Voyager Coffee to relocate to another home within Cupertino (Seema)
  • Championed safer, connected sidewalks and safer intersections throughout the city (Seema)
  • Got the city to adopt a Vision Zero Plan to reduce serious injuries and fatalities in the city (Seema)
  • Got the city to agree in March 2025 to develop an Urban Canopy Plan to increase tree canopy especially on the east side of the city (Seema)
  • And much more

Santosh claims "I am running on a set of accomplishments."

Membership in a group is not an accomplishment. On his website, Santosh Rao cites membership in a number of committees, the Planning Commission, and the Sports Center, but no real results.

Santosh Rao's main accomplishment is that he is a leader of the incumbent "no-growth" group Better Cupertino. Better Cupertino aligned council members - Ray Wang, Liang Chao, Kitty Moore, Darcy Paul, Jon Willey, and Steven Scharf - have held the majority on the City Council for 6 of the past 8 years. Santosh Rao and Tracy Kosolcharoen were both appointed to the Planning Commission in Jan 2025 by the current Better Cupertino aligned Council majority and both are endorsed by the leaders of the Better Cupertino group.

Santosh claims he "led the Planning Commission effort to pass Cupertino’s Oversized Vehicle Ordinance."

This is a misleading statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

This agenda item was discussed in the planning Commission meeting of June 24, 2025. Santosh Rao wanted to impose paid permits on all residents with oversized vehicles, such as RVs. Seema Lindskog successfully advocated for a free annual resident permit, as reflected in Council’s unanimous adoption of the policy.

Santosh claims he "defended Schools & Public Safety: Fought to protect 7th-period electives and school law enforcement cuts during CUSD budget discussions."

This is a false statement by Santosh Rao not based on real facts. 

FUHSD is the primary funder for School Resource Officers in partnership with CUSD, so that CUSD only pays a small portion of the cost. “School law enforcement” was never part of the CUSD budget discussions.

Santosh claims he "advocated to safely reopen schools post-COVID."

CUSD re-opened schools post-COVID via a hybrid instruction model and then a full re-opening based solely on Santa Clara County Department of Public Health and SCC Office of Education recommendations, not based on parent preferences, as those preferences varied dramatically across the spectrum.

Santosh claims he "secured crossing guards at Stevens Creek and Faria Elementary."

Crossing guard allocations are designated by the city’s Transportation staff based on a strict quantitative evaluation of the number of children crossing at an intersection. It is not impacted by individual resident feedback.

Santosh claims he "led the fight to save Movies in the Park at Creekside Park."

The Cupertino Parks and Recreation Department made the decision to centralize Movies in the Park at Creekside Park, rather than keeping them in separate parks in order to retain this event in the wake of significant budget cuts.

Santosh claims he "organized to return Cupertino Library to regular hours."

Library hours are the jurisdiction of the Santa Clara County library district, and the decision was based on COVID guidelines, not resident individual preferences.

Our priorities are an extension of our values.

J.R. Fruen, Seema Lindskog, and John Tang are running as a 3-person team for Cupertino City Council. They are experienced leaders with a track record of getting things done. They are committed to delivering results for residents with a real downtown, vibrant and safe neighborhoods, smart housing choices, effective governance, and a fiscally strong city that works for everyone.